When I began blogging three and a half years ago, I used a blog site* that was geared toward home schoolers.** While I rambled on about many different things (that's a shocker, I know), initially my blog focus was on our home schooling lives. Then I moved over to Typepad and knitting sort of began to take over my posts and now I think I've gotten to the point where the is just a blog about me and my life.
Last night I was reading one of the blogs I subscribe to, The Ever-Changing Life of a Military Wife. Casey, the author was venting about things she labeled "Dumb". Casey is a young military wife and kindergarten teacher stationed in Germany. #4 on her list was this:
4. Home school. And homeschoolers who say the worst day in homeschool is better than the best day in public school. Having a baby doesn't make you a qualified teacher. And while were on the subject- socializing your kid with other unsocialized kids does not alleviate the problem.
I read that and thought, "Hmmm...really." I know that many people do not agree with home schooling, which is fair enough since I don't agree with public schooling. At first, I wanted to just click away and forget about. I could just unsubscribe from her blog and never read it again. She's got the same absolute right to post her thoughts and feelings just like I do. It's her blog. But it is her blog and when she puts something out there for the public to read, then I think she can expect to get a public response.
So I opened up the comment box and composed several comments, all of which I deleted. There was some deep breathing involved while I lectured myself not to type anything that I would not say to her face to face. I don't even know Casey other than what she has revealed of herself on the blog and a snotty and disrespectful comment does nothing to get my point across.
Here is what I commented:
Oh wow. I've enjoyed your blog very much up until today. I go out of my way not to bash the public school system. However, there are a lot of "qualified" teachers out there that I wouldn't trust to educate my dog. I'm not going to bother defending home schooling, since you clearly have your strong opinions about it. But thanks for reminding me why it's the right choice for our family.
And Casey very kindly responded to me with a comment here:
Ah, sorry. I meant no offense to you and to those that take home schooling seriously and do it well. We had two people come into our school this week who have been homeschooling and both of their kids are about a year behind academically. Their parents chose homeschooling for the wrong reasons and the kid suffered. It upset me very much to see. Add that to the PMS and I was pretty pissed off. I totally agree that there are public school teachers I wouldn't trust my kid with. In college I was already making a list of teachers my child could never have. I suppose homeschooling is the same way- very dependent on the teacher.
Okay, see? There was no great conversion to the other's point of view from this exchange, but we were both mature and respectful about it. And the truth is, there ARE some home schoolers out there who perhaps should not be teaching their children at home.
If only I had not returned to her blog to look at more of the comments. Here are some of them:
I have a freakin' law degree and don't feel qualified to homeschool my kids. I can't do math to save my life and should NEVER be trusted to teach my children math. And really, teaching kids out of a work book their entire lives? Um, that doesn't strike me as exceptionally educational. There was a proposed bill in CA a while back that was actually going to make homeschooling (unless you had a teaching license) illegal. I think I would support that, you know, if I lived in CA! And really, how the heck are you supposed to socialize your kids?!?! (Sorry mini-rant, homeschooling is at the top of my "irk list")
Great list :)
Whew. This comment to me seems based in a lack of knowledge. I definitely don't consider myself a math scholar, but I have relearned math right alongside my kids. I know very few home schoolers who teach kids out of a work book their entire lives. Alex spent last year doing nothing but science experiments for that subject, from building a robot to making slime to working with lasers. And the socialization thing just KILLS me. Do they think we keep them locked away all day, out of contact with any other people? Our home school group in Georgia was a great example of kids that were wonderfully socialized. Not only with other home schoolers, but with anyone. I maintain that public school is a completely artificial environment for socialization, often breeding more hostility and defensiveness among children rather than the ability "socialize".
I have never been homeschooled/feel inclined to homeschool, but I have always wondered if those children ever REALLY learn anything.
Hahahaha!!! I say the same thing about public schoolers! This commenter should perhaps talk to some college administrators about the quality of education that most home schoolers exhibit.
My mom is a teacher. She has a new student who just came from a Pace curriculum. If you've never heard of it, it's worse than homeschooling. The kids have workbooks and can finish the assignments at their own pace. What elementary student would ever finish any assignment without a due date? My mom is having lots of problems with that student.
Okay, I know the Pace curriculum and it's definitely not one of my favorites, but that has nothing to do with the format. Worse than homeschooling? I don't even know what that commenter means with this, since Pace is generally used as home schooling curriculum. What elementary student would finish an assignment without a due date? How about an obedient child who understands what is expected? And let me point out that home schooling does involve due dates. Most of us do not hand over the workbooks and tell the child to go ahead, finish it whenever.
home schooled kids are always weird and socially awkward
This is my favorite comment. I wonder how many home schoolers this person has met? That is incredibly sweeping generalization that reveals far more about the commenter than about home schooling. And I can guarantee you does not apply to my children.
A kid who likes home schooling? Of course they do, they don't have to sit in a classroom all day w/a bunch of kids doing work. From what I can tell, most home school kids I've known don't have many friends, they've never had to learn how to deal with conflict, and they don't learn much since they get to play and watch tv all day. School was usually the only break from my parents I got. Not just that, they don't get the joy of group activities or a real class trip. I realize public schools aren't the greatest (boy do I!) but I got a better education there then I would have at home. Just the fact that my parent's couldn't help me out with my homework after the 5th grade should be a indication of that.
I hope this lady never talks to my kids. They are going to be really pissed off to find out that they are supposed to be playing and watching tv all day and I've had them learning! Yes, a home schooling parent has to make the effort to ensure that the kids have the opportunity to experience activities and the conflicts and joys that accompany them, but it's not difficult. And many parents cannot help with the kid's homework because they are not involved in the teaching of it.
Oh my god, you are full of yourself aren't you? How about as the Christian that you claim to be, if you followed that sage advice- if you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all. There are OVER ONE AND A HALF MILLION home schooled children in America, thanks so much for enlightening us all on how you are right and they are all wrong. I feel SO sorry for the kids that you teach and the parents of those kids. I'm pretty sure they'd be better off being home schooled. To the people that actually read this blog and think you are so flipping funny and great, seriously, take a minute to click on the "school" tag and ACTUALLY read what this "teacher" has written. Casey, you make fun of your students, you make fun of the parents, you post pictures of their school work, you post pictures of the kids- do you have the parents permission to do that??? How many of you parents reading this would think it was so funny if that were YOUR kid she was poking fun at and posting pictures of on the internet without your permission? I think its sad you even still have a job teaching children.
Mmm...yeah, that's not helpful. I give Casey credit for leaving this comment up. I consider my blog to be my internet home. If someone came into my actual home and insulted me like that, they would not be welcome. Same here on the blog. I have no issue deleting comments that are rude or offensive. By the end of the comment (and there's more that did not apply to the home schooling issue that I did not include here) the reader is left with only the anger and none of the point of the comment.
I'm not out to convert the whole internet to the wonderful rightness of home schooling. It is a choice that works for our family. I very often have my doubts if this is the best thing for the kids. Moving here, I have contemplated putting them into public school and I may try to have them partipate in the school's extra-academic subjects like art or band this year. I want to challenge them and expand their boundaries, whether it is with me at home or with another system outside the home.
After nine years of home schooling, I have learned that it's not about the academics. Kids can learn in many ways, in many places, from many people. Home schooling is not a ticket to brilliant, well-educated, sophisticated children. It's about the relationship. It's about knowing your kids. It's about learning their strengths and weaknesses and guiding them. It's about expecting the best from them. I did this when they were toddlers, why would I have ceased when they became school age? It's about family.
This sounds like I'm saying that parents who send the kids to public school don't do any of these things. No, not at all. I'm a product of the public schools. But I disagree that just because you are a parent doesn't mean you can teach your child. Oh yes, it does. It's not easy, it's not to be done alone, and it's not perfect. But it is that simple.
*I think that old blog still lives at www.homeschoolblogger.com/not1worry.
**I have a hard time bringing myself to type anything regarding home school as one word. It seems like the combination of the words, as in "homeschooling", "homeschoolers", etc. has become the norm now, but it just seems wrong to me. No one writes "publicschooling" or "privateschoolers".
29 August - Before there's any deceased equine violence, I am closing the comments. Thank you so much to everyone who has respectfully participated in this discussion.